The holiday season is a fantastic time for gathering with loved ones, sharing stories, and, of course, enjoying delicious food. For students, it's also a great opportunity to engage in fun activities that foster connection and critical thinking. One such activity that’s quickly becoming a holiday favorite is using Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions for Students. These questions are designed to get young minds thinking, laughing, and debating, making them a perfect addition to any Thanksgiving celebration or classroom activity.
What Are Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions for Students?
"Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions for Students" are a playful and engaging way to encourage discussion and imaginative thinking. They present two distinct, often humorous or thought-provoking, scenarios, and the participant must choose which one they would rather experience. These aren't simple yes-or-no questions; they require a genuine decision between two potentially challenging or amusing options. They're popular because they break the ice, encourage empathy as students consider their peers' choices, and often lead to hilarious debates. They can be used in a variety of settings:
- In the classroom to start a lesson, as a quick brain break, or as part of a holiday-themed unit.
- At home during family gatherings to spark conversation beyond just who made the best pie.
- At friends' get-togethers for some lighthearted entertainment.
The importance of these questions lies in their ability to promote communication, creativity, and a deeper understanding of different perspectives. They move beyond rote learning and encourage students to articulate their reasoning, a valuable skill in all areas of life. Here's a peek at how they work:
- Scenario A: You can only eat Thanksgiving dinner with a room full of talking turkeys who insist on telling you their life stories.
- Scenario B: You have to wear a turkey costume for the entire Thanksgiving weekend, and it squeaks every time you move.
This simple example shows how the questions create a dilemma, forcing a choice that's not necessarily easy. They can also be structured in different ways:
| Category | Example Question |
|---|---|
| Food Related | Would you rather have mashed potatoes with gravy for every meal for a month, or never eat pumpkin pie again? |
| Family Related | Would you rather have your entire family sing a Thanksgiving song every time you enter a room, or have to wear a pilgrim hat for the whole day? |
Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions: Food Fiascos
Would you rather eat only cranberry sauce for Thanksgiving dinner, or only turkey for Thanksgiving dinner?
Would you rather have all your side dishes be sweet (like candied yams and cranberry sauce), or all your side dishes be savory (like stuffing and green bean casserole)?
Would you rather have to eat your entire Thanksgiving meal with a tiny spoon, or with chopsticks?
Would you rather have your mashed potatoes be super lumpy, or your gravy be extremely watery?
Would you rather have to eat your dessert first, or have to eat your appetizer last?
Would you rather have every piece of candy corn you eat taste like soap, or have every bite of turkey taste like plain lettuce?
Would you rather have to make a pie from scratch using only ingredients you’ve never used before, or have to eat a store-bought pie that someone else has tampered with?
Would you rather have your stuffing be made entirely of marshmallows, or your mashed potatoes be made entirely of popcorn?
Would you rather have to drink gravy instead of water for the day, or have to eat raw vegetables instead of cooked for the day?
Would you rather have your Thanksgiving feast consist of only bread and water, or have your Thanksgiving feast be a single, enormous, unpeelable banana?
Would you rather have to eat a whole raw potato, or a whole raw onion?
Would you rather have your turkey be so dry it’s like sawdust, or your stuffing be so soggy it’s like soup?
Would you rather have to eat your Thanksgiving meal backward (dessert first, then mains, then appetizers), or have to eat your Thanksgiving meal upside down?
Would you rather have every bite of your food be unexpectedly spicy, or every bite of your food be unexpectedly sour?
Would you rather have to drink apple cider that tastes like broccoli, or eat mashed potatoes that taste like bubblegum?
Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions: Family & Friends Funnies
Would you rather have your family reenact the first Thanksgiving every year, or have your family wear historical costumes all day every day?
Would you rather have to sing a song about gratitude every time you wanted something, or have to do a little dance of thanks?
Would you rather have your entire family wear matching, goofy Thanksgiving sweaters for the holiday, or have to wear a pilgrim hat and buckled shoes yourself?
Would you rather have your family members take turns telling embarrassing stories about you all day, or have to tell embarrassing stories about them?
Would you rather have to spend Thanksgiving in a haunted house, or have to spend Thanksgiving on a boat in the middle of a storm?
Would you rather have your family watch only Thanksgiving-themed movies from the 1950s, or have to listen to only Thanksgiving-themed polka music?
Would you rather have to tell a joke to every person you meet on Thanksgiving day, or have to give a compliment to every person you meet?
Would you rather have your family communicate only through interpretive dance on Thanksgiving, or only through animal noises?
Would you rather have to help your parents prepare Thanksgiving dinner for a week straight, or have to clean up after Thanksgiving dinner for a week straight?
Would you rather have your family members all pretend to be historical figures from the first Thanksgiving, or have them all pretend to be characters from your favorite cartoon?
Would you rather have your phone only be able to make calls to your grandparents, or have your phone only be able to receive texts from your cousins?
Would you rather have to give a toast to every person at the table, or have to receive a toast from every person at the table?
Would you rather have to create a Thanksgiving-themed scavenger hunt for your family, or have to write a Thanksgiving poem for everyone?
Would you rather have your entire family do a flash mob dance every time the doorbell rings, or have to wear a turkey tiara for the entire day?
Would you rather have to play a board game with your family where the only goal is to collect "gratitude points," or play a game where you have to act out Thanksgiving traditions?
Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions: Animal Antics
Would you rather have a pet turkey that follows you everywhere, or a pet squirrel that tries to steal your Thanksgiving dinner?
Would you rather have to communicate with all farm animals using only pig grunts, or only chicken clucks?
Would you rather have to share your Thanksgiving feast with a flock of very polite pigeons, or a single, very demanding badger?
Would you rather have your house decorated with live, singing crickets, or have your house decorated with constantly shedding feathers?
Would you rather have to milk a cow for your Thanksgiving cream, or churn butter for your Thanksgiving bread?
Would you rather have a parade of squirrels dressed as pilgrims march through your living room, or have a flock of geese wearing pilgrim hats honk carols outside your window?
Would you rather have to herd a group of confused sheep into a pen, or teach a group of stubborn goats how to play fetch?
Would you rather have your gravy boat be a tiny, live duckling, or have your bread basket be a giant, sleeping hamster?
Would you rather have to pet a porcupine with fuzzy gloves on, or try to hug a grumpy badger?
Would you rather have your Thanksgiving centerpiece be a talking parrot that only squawks compliments, or a family of very well-behaved mice that perform a Thanksgiving play?
Would you rather have to share your bed with a friendly but smelly skunk, or have to share your plate with a mischievous raccoon?
Would you rather have to wear a vest made of wool from a sheep you just sheared, or wear a hat made of straw from a field you just harvested?
Would you rather have to answer all your questions in barks and meows, or answer all your questions by flapping your arms?
Would you rather have to wrestle a very large, friendly bear for a piece of pie, or have to outsmart a group of clever foxes to get a dinner roll?
Would you rather have your entire Thanksgiving dinner served by intelligent, but very literal, robotic chickens, or by a team of hyperactive, overly enthusiastic puppies?
Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions: School Spirit Snafus
Would you rather have your entire school have a mandatory Thanksgiving sing-along in the cafeteria every day, or have to write a thank-you note to every teacher and staff member at school?
Would you rather have your principal dress up as a turkey for the entire school week, or have to wear a pilgrim outfit every Friday?
Would you rather have your school lunch be Thanksgiving leftovers every day for a month, or have your school lunch be only Brussels sprouts every day for a month?
Would you rather have to give a presentation on the history of Thanksgiving in a funny accent every day, or have to sing a song about thankfulness during every class change?
Would you rather have to decorate your entire classroom with only paper turkeys you’ve made, or have to write a gratitude journal entry for every student in your class?
Would you rather have your school’s mascot dress up as a pilgrim and lead Thanksgiving exercises, or have students wear historically inaccurate costumes to school?
Would you rather have to help organize a school-wide food drive with only two days' notice, or have to bake a pie for every student in your class?
Would you rather have to volunteer at a soup kitchen for the entire Thanksgiving break, or have to spend the break helping a struggling family with their chores?
Would you rather have your school hold a talent show where everyone has to perform a Thanksgiving-themed act, or have a school-wide "thankfulness olympics"?
Would you rather have to write an essay about your favorite Thanksgiving memory for every subject, or have to draw a Thanksgiving scene for every subject?
Would you rather have to wear a Pilgrim hat every day of November, or have to speak in rhyme every day of November?
Would you rather have to organize a "gratitude graffiti" wall in the school hallway, or a "kindness chain" for the whole school?
Would you rather have to personally thank every student who donates to the food drive, or personally thank every teacher who participates in a Thanksgiving craft?
Would you rather have your entire school field trip be to a turkey farm, or to a pumpkin patch?
Would you rather have to give a speech about what you’re thankful for to the entire school assembly, or have to lead a Thanksgiving craft session for the kindergarteners?
Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions: Weird & Wonderful Wishes
Would you rather have the ability to talk to food, or the ability to fly but only when you’re wearing a turkey costume?
Would you rather have your house filled with the smell of pumpkin spice for the rest of your life, or the smell of cinnamon?
Would you rather have to wear shoes made of pie crust, or a hat made of mashed potatoes?
Would you rather have your dreams be entirely about Thanksgiving parades, or entirely about competitive pie-eating contests?
Would you rather have to sing opera every time you sneeze, or have to yodel every time you laugh?
Would you rather have a tiny, invisible turkey that follows you everywhere and whispers compliments, or a giant, friendly scarecrow that follows you and tells you jokes?
Would you rather have to eat your meals while sitting on a giant marshmallow, or while balanced on a wobbly Jell-O mold?
Would you rather have your tears taste like gravy, or your sweat taste like whipped cream?
Would you rather have to hop on one foot everywhere you go for a week, or wear oven mitts on your hands for a week?
Would you rather have your shadow be a Thanksgiving turkey, or have your reflection be a pilgrim?
Would you rather have to communicate with everyone using only gestures and charades, or by drawing pictures?
Would you rather have your superpower be the ability to make any food taste like your favorite food, or the ability to make any song sound like your favorite song?
Would you rather have to wear a necklace made of dried cranberries, or earrings made of tiny corn cobs?
Would you rather have a personal chef who can only cook Thanksgiving dishes, or a personal masseuse who only knows turkey-themed massages?
Would you rather have to talk like a pirate on Thanksgiving day, or talk like a robot?
Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions: Gratitude & Giving
Would you rather have to volunteer at a homeless shelter for a whole day, or donate a significant portion of your allowance to charity?
Would you rather have to write a heartfelt letter of gratitude to every person who has helped you this year, or perform a random act of kindness for a stranger every day for a week?
Would you rather have to spend Thanksgiving Day helping out at an animal shelter, or spend it helping out at a senior living home?
Would you rather have the ability to grant one person's wish for happiness, or the ability to solve one person's biggest problem?
Would you rather have to teach someone a new skill you possess, or learn a new skill from someone else?
Would you rather have to organize a neighborhood food drive, or organize a community cleanup day?
Would you rather have to share your favorite toy with someone who has never had one before, or share your favorite book with someone who has never read?
Would you rather have to spend your Thanksgiving break learning about different cultures and traditions, or sharing your own culture with others?
Would you rather have the power to end one injustice in the world, or the power to inspire millions to be more compassionate?
Would you rather have to create a "gratitude jar" for your family and write down something you’re thankful for each day, or have to leave anonymous notes of appreciation for people around you?
Would you rather have to spend your Thanksgiving volunteering to help people less fortunate, or spend it donating your time and resources to a cause you believe in?
Would you rather have the ability to inspire one person to be truly thankful for what they have, or the ability to make someone who is lonely feel loved and appreciated?
Would you rather have to lead a group in creating care packages for soldiers, or lead a group in making blankets for the homeless?
Would you rather have to write a poem or song about the importance of giving, or create a piece of art that represents thankfulness?
Would you rather have to dedicate your Thanksgiving to helping those who are struggling, or to celebrating the abundance and blessings in your own life?
Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions for Students offer a delightful and insightful way to engage with the spirit of the season. Whether used for a quick classroom laugh, a deep family discussion, or just a fun way to pass the time, these questions are sure to spark joy, critical thinking, and memorable moments for students of all ages.